It’s another politics community! As part of the continuing fallout of pretty much everyone bashing [email protected] for being objectively horrible, I decided to make one. Let’s see how it goes.
General guidelines are, more or less: You can be a dick, but don’t argue in bad faith. Less strictness in terms of “only post what I want you to post” than some of the existing options. You can take any viewpoint you want to take, but you may have to defend it. No drive-by shouted opinions, no abusiveness, no obvious propaganda or trash sources.
Detailed rules follow. Let me know if you want to help moderate. I expect that traffic will be a little slow for the beginning but as work ramps up it would presumably be good to have others involved.
Any politics anywhere in the world. Inevitably it’ll be 99% US stuff, but that’s not a rule.
This community works differently to how most politics communities work. It has strict rules designed to facilitate productive discussion. You can be rude, to a point, but you can’t participate in bad faith:
- If you claim someone said something they didn’t say, that’s a temp ban.
- If you make a factual claim but then aren’t interested in backing it up, that’s a temp ban.
- If you’re asked one or two reasonable questions about what you said, and you’re still talking but you’re pretending the questions didn’t happen or rejecting the premise of answering them, that’s a temp ban.
The idea is to make the discussion productive. Let’s see how it works. Maybe this is a fool’s errand but IDK how any set of moderation could be worse than lemmy.world.
Other misc rules:
- Reliable sources only.
- Keep it productive please.
- Self posts for discussion are fine. This includes videos or photos. No meme posts or screenshots please.
- No personal insults.
- No racism / transphobia / related bigotry.
As Rimu is fine with both, I would really please ask you to consider !uspolitics. Or if you want external feedback, we can open a thread on whatever community you see fit (could be [email protected] , but also [email protected] as it’s related too) to get additional feedback from users.
It may seem like it’s a pet peeve, but really, it’s something that’s been on the mind of a lot of people that lemmy.world, a server hosted and managed in the Netherlands, gets its main “politics” community dedicated to the USA. I’ve seen users being kind of irritated by it, and I would like to avoid a similar kind of feeling towards piefed.social.
I know piefed.social is based in New Zealand, but you get the idea.
A potential solution is
Note that your concern about the world community not being used it true for news as well, still [email protected] and the several country-dedicated communities (e.g. [email protected] , [email protected] ) are all active
you can maybe keep it and just lock it, with links to the communities listed above. That prevents someone else from taking that community name.